Kris Allen Wins American Idol — Culture Warrior or Just All Around Great Guy?
Saturday, May 23rd, 2009
Last Wed. eve this years’ American Idol was announced. After nearly 100 million votes, 23-year-old Kris Allen from Conway, Ark won — and it’s reported that the voting wasn’t even all that close. Not that this will change the course of world events, but AI is the highest rated regular show on network television — the last of the “water cooler” shows. What makes this year particularly poignant is that the winner wasn’t the best singer — not by a long shot. Adam Lambert can “sing the phone book” as Randy Jackson often proclaims, and it would sound terrific. He had far more range, far more stage presence, much greater vocal skills and excellent enunciation of the lyrics. Superior all around. So, why did Kris win?
First, Kris might not have been great, but he is damn good! Second, his humble manner and absolute genuineness comes across particularly well, and the American Idol home audience really seems to warm up to those traits. Third, many would say this is the biggie, Kris Allen isn’t overtly gay — while Adam Lambert was comfortable glamming with the best of them.
As we out here in the Golden State (is granola “gold”?) gird our loins for Tuesday’s ruling by our Supreme Court on the challenge to Proposition 8, the Constitutional amendment that re-established the meaning of marriage as “between one man and one woman”, one has to consider that our mainstream media notwithstanding — the day-in, day-out common American is not gung ho on championing the gay/lesbian lifestyle as an accepted standard. Tolerated, fine. What we should encourage our children to emulate? Not so much.
But, as they keep saying on the show — “It’s a SINGING competition”. Therefore, the best singer should win? It’s also a “performance” competition, and talent is only part of a performance. There has to be that connection to the viewer, that spark to make tens of millions of folks to reach over, dial or text their vote. The guys are showing us the way through this cultural quagmire, as they seem to be good friends. As a writer over at TMZ blog states: “Just because several million more people like one over the other, it doesn’t mean “American Idol” champ Kris Allen and runner-up Adam Lambert can’t enjoy a meal together.” Adam Lambert is gonna do just fine . . .
Kris Allen — you ARE, the American Idol. Good luck to both of ya!







